This is a Tapestry page Version 25.2 (25.2-release r2502261737) 1ec5a492cd94a2f98a2b4b984b08303bc31e4505 (forums/v4/ForumTopicPage) [ES read true ES write true] [ Node ID: AC9-162-5 Master Node: true Host: redis-cluster ]
cancel
Showing results for 
Search instead for 
Did you mean: 

No pillarboxing on dvd players for 4:3 content?

JSantiago
Trusted Contributor

No pillarboxing on dvd players for 4:3 content?

so i had this dvd player a few years ago which like most players can be set for either a 4:3 tv or 16:9. it could also play divx, and if they're at 4:3 aspect ratio they are pillarboxed (black bars on the side) without having to change any television settings. however, if a 4:3 regular dvd disc is played, it is not pillarboxed but stretched to fill the entire screen, distorting the picture. 

now i got this new dvd player. generally i'm satisfied with it BUT, because it has an HDMI output, i thought as long as the tv type is set for 16:9, pillarboxing will also work on regular 4:3 dvd's. well, not the case. also only works with divx even through HDMI. 

so i wonder, are there dvd players out there that DO support pillarboxing for regular dvd discs, and i happen to have a player that does not? or is that common? 

on my pc and streamer i don't have that problem. 4:3 content is pillarboxed in whatever file format including dvd's.

Escalate